What is Rosaleen's response when Lily asks why she never told her what she knew about her mother?

• A. I didn’t tell you before because I was afraid
• B. Why would I go and hurt you with something like that
• C. I didn’t think you wanted to know
• D. I hoped you would never ask

Answer: (B)

The main idea being tested is Rosaleen’s protective instinct when Lily asks about her mother. The line she uses shows she would rather protect Lily from emotional pain than push the truth on her at that moment. Rosaleen cares for Lily deeply and understands that some truths can be more hurtful than helpful, especially since Lily is young and already dealing with uncertainty about her mother. By saying, “Why would I go and hurt you with something like that,” she signals that her silence is an act of care, meant to shield Lily from painful information.

The other options don’t fit as well because they imply motives like fear, assuming Lily doesn’t want to know, or hoping Lily would never ask. None of those capture the tenderness and protective rationale behind Rosaleen’s choice to avoid sharing painful details.